Blog Entry

Greatest Packer QB?

Posted on: October 20, 2010 4:24 am
 

Who is the greatest Packer QB? A question that most people have recently answered with a quick "Brett Favre", but is he really? There was another QB in Green Bay that might have a claim to the title, Bart Starr. Both played for 16 years, both have been on championship teams, so let's compare some statistics of the two.


Bart Starr 1956-1971, 94-57-6 record

Attempts-3,149
Completions-1,808
Yards-24,718
Completion%-57.4
TDs-152
Int-138
QB Rating-80.5
Rushes-247
Yards-1,308
YPC-5.3
Fumbles-64

He was the 1966 NFL MVP.


Brett Favre 1992-2007, 160-93-0 record


Attempts-8,754
Completions-5,377
Yards-61,655
Completion%-61.4
TDs-442
Int-286
QB Rating-85.8
Rushes-555
Yards-1,786
YPC-3.2
Fumbles-147

He was the 1995-1997 NFL MVP.




Statistically, Favre dominates. Better completion percentage, better TD/Int ratio, more wins, more yards, etc. However, when it came to the playoffs, the picture changes.


Bart Starr

Playoff record 9-1
TDs-15
Int-3
MVP of the first two Super Bowls, 5 Championships

Brett Favre

Playoff record 12-10
TDs-39
Int-28
1 Championship


Here, Starr dominates. Better winning percentage, better TD/Int ratio, more championships.


So, the question is...who was the greatest Packer QB? A player that dominated statwise throughout the regular season and led his team to 1 championship, or a player that was at his best when it mattered most? Personally, I'll take the limited mistakes and 5 championships over the stats and 1 title.

Category: NFL
Comments
Einsamer Wolf
Since: Jul 17, 2008
Posted on: July 4, 2011 2:11 am
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator



The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or CBSSports.com